Older than the moment
A Friday evening. Your best friend cancels at short notice, with a perfectly reasonable explanation. Still, afterwards you sit on the sofa feeling as if you were eight years old and nobody had invited you to their birthday party. Or the other way around: after a long day, your partner just wants to talk, and everything inside you tightens, as if someone were about to lock a door.
Reactions like these are often older than the situation. John Bowlby, the founder of attachment theory, described how we form inner images from our experiences with closeness: Am I worth being cared for? Can I rely on others? He called these images internal working models. They help us size up new situations quickly. But they also make us tend to read the new in the light of the old.
So the question of where your attachment style comes from is really the question: where did you learn these images? The answer has several chapters.
The first chapter: what children learn about closeness
Every person comes into the world with an attachment system, a protective program that seeks the closeness of familiar people when we’re afraid. The need is innate. How the system gets set, a child learns in the first few years.
The researcher Mary Ainsworth observed this closely in the 1970s. She watched toddlers with their caregivers in a playroom, during a short separation and at the reunion. From this, she described patterns that are still the basis of research today. Simplified:
| How closeness was often experienced | What the attachment system learned | How it can show up today |
|---|---|---|
| Mostly sensitive and reliable | “When I need comfort, someone comes.” | Being able to lean on others, calming down again |
| Sometimes very attentive, sometimes hard to reach | “I have to be loud and watchful, or I’ll miss out on closeness.” | The alarm goes off quickly, anxious style |
| Wishes for closeness tended to be rebuffed | “It’s safer to need nothing.” | Feelings get turned down, avoidant style |
| The protective person was frightening or very frightened themselves | “Where do I go when comfort and fear come from the same person?” | Wanting and fearing closeness at the same time |
The last row goes back to Mary Main and Judith Solomon. They described toddlers who approached their caregiver and froze mid-movement. Mary Main and Erik Hesse later found indications that this disorganized behavior often develops where the person who was supposed to give protection caused fear themselves or was very frightened themselves. Whether the fearful-avoidant style in adults follows directly from this hasn’t been settled. The two are related, but they aren’t the same.
What matters in this table is the middle column. Each of these strategies was a smart response to the situation a child was in at the time. If you experience unpredictable attention, it makes sense to stay watchful. If your wishes for closeness get rebuffed, you protect yourself by no longer showing them.
How experiences become an inner voice
Mario Mikulincer and Phillip Shaver describe how attachment experiences become part of us. We don’t just take on expectations of others, but also the way we were treated. If you were comforted, you learn to comfort yourself. If you were encouraged, you learn to encourage yourself. And if you were often criticized, you learn to criticize yourself.
That’s why your inner voice sometimes sounds so familiar in difficult moments. The sentence “Stop making such a fuss” that you tell yourself after a disappointment may once have belonged to someone else.
Not just the parents
When childhood comes up, most people immediately think of mother and father. But siblings, grandparents, a nanny, teachers, a coach or your first best friend also leave traces. So does what happens in a family: one move after another, a divorce, an illness, a parent who was exhausted for years.
Some of these experiences are hard. In the large ACE study with more than 9000 adults, Vincent Felitti and colleagues showed that adverse childhood experiences such as abuse, domestic violence or a parent with addiction problems are common: more than half of the respondents reported at least one. The more such experiences, the higher the risk of later health problems on average. But a risk isn’t fate. Many people with difficult beginnings later lead good lives and have secure relationships.
The later chapters
Attachment stays in motion throughout life, and several findings show this.
Patterns can shift. Everett Waters and colleagues assessed people’s attachment as babies and again 20 years later. 72 percent had the same classification. But in more than one in four people it had changed, often after drastic events like the loss of a parent or a divorce. Chris Fraley summarized many such studies and concludes: early experiences form a basic pattern that never completely disappears. New experiences keep being layered on top of it, and the longer and more often we experience something new, the more weight it gets.
Later relationships help write it, in both directions. Joanne Davila, Benjamin Karney and Thomas Bradbury followed newlywed couples. On average, the partners became more securely attached over time, especially if they were satisfied with the relationship. Conversely, a relationship in which you never knew where you stood can turn the alarm up for the first time in adulthood. Not every anxious style comes from childhood.
You aren’t the same in every relationship. Jennifer La Guardia and colleagues asked people how secure they felt with different people: with their mother, father, partner and best friend. The same people didn’t feel equally secure with everyone. How secure depended strongly on how much each person supported their needs for connection, autonomy and competence. So an attachment style is also a response to the people you’re dealing with right now.
What your background doesn’t explain
It’s tempting to look for a single cause: the strict mother, the absent father, that one breakup. Research rarely allows for that. It shows average connections, not a formula for an individual person.
One of the most important discoveries on this comes from Mary Main, Nancy Kaplan and Jude Cassidy. They had adults talk about their childhood in a detailed interview. What mattered most for assessing attachment wasn’t what had happened, but how people talked about it. Those who could talk about difficult things coherently and in a balanced way were often classified as secure, even if their childhood had been hard. Insecure accounts sounded different: some could barely remember anything and called everything “perfectly normal” without being able to find an example. Others got tangled up while telling their story, and were still very angry or confused today.
That’s hopeful news. The past can’t be changed. How you understand it can. The article “Earned security: How people become secure despite a difficult childhood” describes in more detail people who become secure despite difficult beginnings. And if the question of blame is getting loud for you right now, you’ll find a fair look at it in “Are my parents to blame? A fair look at your own history”.
Exploring your own story
You don’t have to start therapy to see a little more clearly. A few questions are enough to begin with. Take a quiet half hour and write down your answers.
- How were feelings handled in your family? What happened when you were sad, angry or afraid? Were you comforted, distracted, scolded, met with silence?
- Whom did you go to when you weren’t doing well? And if nobody comes to mind: what did you do instead?
- Which later relationships shaped you? Think of one that made you more secure and one after which you were more cautious.
- With whom are you different today? Are there people with whom your alarm hardly goes off? What do they do differently?
None of this is about finding someone to blame. It’s about understanding why your system reacts the way it does. Once you understand that, you have more room to move: you can recognize the alarm as an old acquaintance instead of simply obeying it.
When the memories are heavy
For some people, looking back isn’t just uncomfortable, it’s painful. If your story includes violence, abuse or severe neglect, you shouldn’t work through it alone with an article or a course. Psychotherapy is a good, safe place for that.
In Switzerland, you can find psychotherapists through psychologie.ch, for example. Since 2022, basic health insurance has covered psychological psychotherapy when it’s prescribed by a doctor. Ask your family doctor about it.
Keep readingCan you change your attachment style?


